Team Archives
20th Jan, 2009
Canucks In A Race Against Time

13th Jan, 2009
Canucks In The Thick Of Things

Full Archive

NHL Columns
Search
RealGM Poll
Which team needed to improve themselves the most for a Stanley Cup run?

Chicago
Vancouver
Ottawa
San Jose
New Jersey
Buffalo
Phoenix
Detroit
Colorado
Los Angeles
Other



Poll Archives
At A Crossroads: Why Luongo Might Be Hurting The Canucks
Matthew Falvai. 8th February, 2009 - 9:42 pm


Current Features
CHICAGO:
Young Hawks Strike Fear In NHL

TORONTO:
Looking For An Active Toronto Trade Deadline

NEW JERSEY:
Grading The Deal: Devils Win Kovy Sweepstakes

LOS ANGELES:
Monarchy On The Horizon

ANAHEIM:
Hot Ducks Could Land A Déjà vu Matchup With Defending Champs

ST. LOUIS:
Look To The Future, Ode To The Past

N.Y. ISLANDERS:
The Islanders Flip The Switch

COLORADO:
Looking Back, Moving Forward: Avalanche Surprisingly Ho-Hum At Break

COLUMBUS:
Mason Has Columbus Believing

WASHINGTON:
Alexander The Great Leading The Charge In Capital City

N.Y. RANGERS:
The Rangers Are Bound For Failure

ATLANTA:
The John Tavares’ Sweepstakes Begins In Atlanta

PITTSBURGH:
What Has Happened To Crosby And Company?

BOSTON:
Add The Bruins To Championship Contenders In Boston

SAN JOSE:
Behind San Jose's Absurdly Dominant Start

MINNESOTA:
A Shot Of 'Wild' Energy

DETROIT:
Talented ‘Wings Work To Cure Potent Disease

PHILADELPHIA:
Not Time To Panic For Fly Guys; Not Yet Anyway

OTTAWA:
Line Dancing

CAROLINA:
Auditing The Carolina Hurricanes, 2007-08

MONTREAL:
Price Joins Roy And Dryden In Montreal Rookie Lore

TAMPA BAY:
Auditing The Tampa Bay Lightning, 2007-2008

DALLAS:
Grading The Deal: Richards And Homqvist To Dallas

BUFFALO:
Sabres Struggles Continue

CALGARY:
Difficult Decisions Ahead For Sutter

EDMONTON:
Stanley Cup Contenders To Laughing Stock


RealGM Search
Search:

The Canucks have their swagger back, but is that what they really want?

Soon-to-be unrestricted free-agents Daniel and Henrik Sedin are reportedly looking for long-term contracts worth around $7 million per season. Now, considering that reigning Conn Smythe champion Henrik Zetterberg recently signed for only $6 million, you'd have to think Canucks' general manager Mike Gillis will be using Marc Savard's $5 million deal as a more appropriate comparable.

All three players produce at a point-a-game rate, and have all faced criticism for being 'soft.'

The problem in the NHL however, is that there are twenty-nine other teams, and you'd have to think at least one of them will offer the big money.

And this is Vancouver's biggest problem.

It doesn't make sense to lose the Sedin brothers for nothing. But how do you explain trading away your two top offensive players in the midst of a very intense playoff hunt?

Here is where Roberto Luongo causes a problem for Vancouver. Because the Canucks, should never have been in this hunt in the first place.

When former executive Dave Nonis took over three years ago, and began dismantling the former core of the team, he was met with a big surprise when off-loading troubled star Todd Bertuzzi.

Instead of receiving prospects and picks, he was handed an amazing gift in the world's best goaltender.

Luongo gave the Canucks a chance to win every night, and they managed to squeak into the playoffs, which is the absolute worst thing that can happen to rebuilding team.

Does anyone really believe this team, led by the Sedins, Mats Sundin, Pavol Demitra and a fragile, penalty-taking defense has any chance with Detroit or San Jose if they make the playoffs?

Of course not.

If logic dictated life, the Sedins, Luongo and Mattias Ohlund would be converted into as much future as you can get.

Ryan Kesler, Alex Burrows, and Alex Edler would be kept long-term as the core of the team, and they would play the waiting game as blue chip prospects Cody Hodgson, Michael Grabner, and goaltending phenom Cory Schneider develop.

But we all know how this story will unfold.

Vancouver is a hockey-mad city. Their owners have publicly announced they want to win now, and as long as Luongo is around, it will be exciting, but inescapably pointless.
All content © 2000-2010 RealGM, L.L.C. All rights reserved..
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising Opportunities | About Us | Site Map | Contact RealGM